• Home
  • About
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Medical Disclaimer

Why Are Some Food Additives That Are Banned In Europe Still Used in the U.S.?

September 24, 2022 by Editor

Some food additives found in common items in grocery stores in the United States are not allowed in Europe. Additionally, different drugs and hormones given to farm animals to promote growth or increase milk production are not permitted in the European Union.

Different continents have different laws concerning food additives. In the United States, the FDA has deemed certain additives to be safe, while in Europe these same additives are considered a cancer risk. It is important to be aware of these differences when eating food from different continents.

When It Comes to Additives, U.S. Regulators Focus on Probability, EU Considers Possibilities

According to Justin J. Kastner, PhD, associate professor in the department of diagnostic medicine and pathobiology at Kansas State University in Manhattan, Europeans take a more cautious approach to evaluating chemicals and additives than Americans do.

One key difference between the United States and the European Union is that the United States has been more focused on the probability of hazards or bad things occurring, while the European Union approach has been more precautionary; they give attention to not just the probability of something going wrong, but also the mere possibility.

Food Industry Lobbying Helps Shape Policy in the U.S.

“The European Union is more conservative in regulating food additives,” said Sheela Sathyanarayana, an expert on the subject. Sathyanarayana is currently serving on a US government panel that advises on chemicals.

Sathyanarayana says that another difference between the United States and Europe is that the food industry has a very strong lobbying presence in the United States, and that this difference often results in the creation of regulation and policy around additives that is different in the two regions.

FDA Lags Behind Europe in Updating Regulations and Reevaluating Additives

The United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) revised the Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA) so that chemicals may be evaluated before they are put on the market, but this revision does not address the legacy of decades of chemicals that are already in circulation, says Sathyanarayana.

In contrast to the European food chemical review system, which recently implemented a system of reevaluating all approved food chemicals, the American system has not changed, according to Maegan McBride, MPH, science policy associate at the Center for Science in the Public Interest (CSPI) in Washington, D.C.

The Center for Science in the Public Interest is a consumer advocacy organization that was founded in 1971. The organization provides practical and science-based advice on food safety.

“Because the United States doesn't have a system in place for reevaluation, it means that certain chemicals haven't been reevaluated since they were first approved, which could have been any number of years ago,” says McBride. “It's important to reevaluate because the field of toxicology is always progressing,” she adds.

Consumer Preference Is Helping to Reduce Use of Food Additives

The food industry has changed in recent years as consumers have become more interested in healthy, natural, and organic food. “Almost every manufacturer has a natural or alternative product line,” says Sathyanarayana. She believes that this trend toward healthier food choices will continue in the future as manufacturers try to eliminate harmful ingredients from their products.

Food Additives and Cancer: What’s the Evidence?

According to McBride, it can be challenging to determine the cancer risk of additives in humans.

She says that it is unethical to conduct a randomized placebo-controlled trial in humans when there is a chemical of concern or it is suspected that the chemical is associated with an adverse outcome, such as cancer.

It would be unethical to give someone a substance that might hurt them. This makes it difficult to get very strong evidence in humans and why animal testing is common in these cases, or more observational studies in humans.

Although lab studies may not always be able to predict if a substance will cause cancer, most substances which are found to cause cancer in lab animals are also found to cause cancer in people, according to the American Cancer Society. Carcinogens often have a much higher effect on animals than on people, so it can be difficult to determine risk. However, the American Cancer Society believes that if a substance is found to cause cancer in animals, then it is reasonable to assume that lowering human exposure to that substance will reduce risk.

Chemicals and additives that are known to cause cancer in animals are sometimes called possible human carcinogens, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC).

Additives That Are Banned in Europe That Are Allowed in the U.S.

Here’s a rundown of food additives that aren’t allowed in Europe but are still used in the United States:

Titanium Dioxide

This additive, which is used for coloring, can be found in Skittles, Starburst, baked goods, soups, broths, sauces, and sandwich spreads. “Titanium dioxide can build up over time — it isn’t excreted very well,” says Sathyanarayana.

“The additive has been shown to be genotoxic in studies” means that the additive has been shown to damage DNA in studies. “Genotoxicity refers to the ability of a chemical substance to damage DNA” means that genotoxicity is the ability of a chemical substance to damage DNA. “Which is the genetic material in all cells” means that DNA is the genetic material in all cells. “And it may lead to carcinogenic, or cancerous, effects” means that genotoxicity may lead to cancerous effects.

The European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) has announced that it no longer considers titanium dioxide to be a safe food additive, due to lack of evidence on its toxic effects. Although there is no conclusive evidence that titanium dioxide is harmful, the EFSA is unable to rule out the possibility that it may be genotoxic. Consequently, they have been unable to establish a safe level of daily intake for the additive.

Even though it's probable that the additive will be outlawed eventually according to the EFSA's suggestion, it hasn't occurred yet. The European Commission and Member States have yet to make that decision. As of now, neither the CSPI nor the EFSA have given suggestions on whether people should stop consuming titanium dioxide.

Potassium Bromate

This additive is used in white flour, bread, and rolls to increase the volume of the bread and give it a fine crumb (not crusty) structure. Most bromate rapidly breaks down to form bromide, which is harmless. However, bromate has been shown to cause cancer in animals, and trace amounts of the chemical may remain in bread which could potentially be a small health risk to consumers, says McBride.

Bromate has been banned in many countries around the world, but it is still used in Japan and the United States. The Center for Science in the Public Interest has petitioned the FDA to ban bromate, and they recommend that consumers avoid this additive. Many millers and bakers have stopped using bromate, but it is still used in California. The organization says that this is because a cancer warning may have to be included on the label.

In 1986, California creates a law called proposition 65 that requires businesses to provide warnings on product labels if some chemical in the product could potentially cause cancer, birth defects, or other reproductive harm. Some experts on food and product safety see California as a model or guide for this type of regulation.

Azodicarbonamide 

This additive is typically found in bread and other baked goods that come in packages, McBride says.


CSPI claims that two dangerous chemicals are produced when azodicarbonamide is baked. One of these chemicals, semicarbazide, is not harmful to humans. However, the other chemical, urethane, is a known cancer-causing agent.

CSPI recommends avoiding azodicarbonamide because there is a small chance it is harmful, and it is not necessary for the food supply.

Butylated Hydroxyanisole (BHA) and Butylated Hydroxytoluene (BHT)

The additives prevent oils and fats in food from going bad, explains McBride.

There is a risk of cancer associated with BHA, according to her. A study conducted previously discovered that BHA caused cancer in the stomachs of rats and as a result, the IARC concluded that the additive should be classified as a carcinogen. In 2011, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services reported that there was enough evidence to say that BHA is likely carcinogenic in humans. Because of this, the CSPI advises people to avoid consuming it.

The chemical cousin to BHA, BHT, is often used together according to the Environmental Working Group (EWG), a nonprofit that works to protect public health. It has been shown to cause developmental effects and thyroid changes in animals, and while it's not officially classified as a carcinogen, there have been studies where rats fed BHT have developed cancer.

The EWG suggests that BHT should be avoided, especially when it is used in conjunction with BHA.

How to Avoid Potentially Risky Food Additives

The current regulatory system in the United States leaves much of the work of figuring out what’s safe or unsafe to the consumer, says Sathyanarayana. If you want to eliminate or reduce food additives in your diet, she offers these tips:

If possible, eat fresh or frozen fruits and vegetables. It's best to eat these instead of processed foods, she says.

You need to be practical. We live in an industrialized world and people are working a lot so we don't have time to make everything from scratch. You can make a lot of good food using frozen ingredients which don't require all the washing and chopping that some fresh vegetables do.

Sathyanarayana says that it is a burden to ask consumers to read product labels, but that if they do, they will typically select foods with fewer ingredients.

If you want to be sure the food you are eating is healthy, look for foods that are labeled “organic.” These foods are not allowed to use ingredients that could be harmful to humans, and any synthetic ingredients that they do use are reviewed every five years.

Utilize outside help by searching for resources. Consumer advocate groups, for example CSPI or EWG, offer suggestions of additives to either reduce or get rid of.

Aside from asking the waiter about your meal, you can also download apps that will help you pick out safe foods to eat. If you type in “food ingredients scanner” on the App Store, two apps that come up are Sift Food Labels and Ingredio. These apps use pictures of food ingredients from the label or bar code to tell you if there are any risky additives in the food.

Sathyanarayana says to look for snack bars with fewer, more natural ingredients. She suggests looking for bars with only a few recognizable ingredients like nuts, nut butters, or fruits.

When it comes to food, you don't have to go to extremes. According to Sathyanarayana, it's more important to focus on reducing your exposure to processed foods and increasing your intake of nutrient-rich options. So don't feel like you have to cut out all unhealthy foods, but rather try to limit your consumption of things like highly-processed snacks that are high in additives.

What are food ingredients and food additives?

Next, we'll examine the difference between food ingredients and food additives.

The term “ingredient” refers to any substance or product used in the manufacture or preparation of food that is still present in the finished product. This includes things like flavorings, food additives, and food enzymes. It does not include residues. Common types of ingredients include preservatives, sweeteners, color additives, flavors and spices, and nutrients.

Food additives are substances used during the preparation of food for a variety of reasons, such as preserving, coloring, or sweetening. The EU defines food additives as “any substance not normally consumed as a food in itself and not normally used as a characteristic ingredient of food, whether or not it has nutritive value.”

A food ingredient is any substance that is added to food. This includes food additives, which must be listed on the ingredient label of any food that contains them.

Which food ingredients and additives are banned in the EU?

Now let’s take a look at some examples of food ingredients and additives that are banned in the EU:

  1. Potassium bromate
  2. Azodicarbonamide
  3. Brominated vegetable oil (BVO)
  4. Olestra
  5. Titanium dioxide (TiO2)
  6. Sudan dyes
  7. Auramine O (AO)
  8. Rhodamine B
  9. Propylparaben
  10. Artificial colors (Yellow No. 5, No. 6, Red No. 40)

Only food additives that are listed in the EU legislation are allowed to be added to food, and this can only be done under specific conditions. The additives that are authorized for use in food and their conditions of use can be found in Annex II of Regulation (EC) No 1333/2008 on food additives[8]. There is also a food additive database available on the European Commission website for the public to search for permitted food additives[9].

BHA and BHT are still allowed as food additives in the United States, even though they are banned in the EU.

How does the ban affect food companies?

The European Union has banned the use of artificial sweeteners, preservatives, and other additives in food after scientific research indicated that they could potentially be harmful to human health. This means that food companies will have to ensure that their products do not contain these substances in order to be safe for consumers. Here are some of the potential impacts:

  • First, foods containing banned ingredients are not allowed to be sold. Companies trying to sell their products in Europe will encounter more barriers to market entry.
  • Second, it will force food manufacturers to change what can be used as ingredients in food products, which opens opportunities for the emergence of new and healthier food choices.
  • Third, there will be a disruption in food companies’ supply chain, as they may have to switch to suppliers who can provide alternative ingredients at the same price point and allow companies to retain the same food characteristics.
  • The advertising strategies of food manufacturers and retailers may change along with the new buying behaviors of consumers.

The ban will prevent food manufacturers from selling their products immediately. It is important to note that these regulations will not only change food manufacturing and buying habits, but also have a domino effect on other areas of business, such as nutrition, health, innovation, and market share.

 

Related posts:

20 Foods to Help You Lose Weight

6 Common Injuries You Should Never Try to Train Through

Greatest Triceps Workout routines



Get the Dietworks Newsletter

Name

Learn More About the Keto Diet

Categories

  • Featured
  • Fitness
    • Cardio
    • Exercises for women
    • Over 50 fitness
    • Pilates
    • Running
    • Speed up Metabolism
    • Walking
    • Weight Lifting
    • Yoga
  • Healthy Diets
  • Healthy Drinks
  • Keto Diet
  • Mega
  • Supplements
  • Weight Loss

Recent Posts

  • Best Cardio Workouts for Women
  • 5 Powerful Bone Broth Health Benefits (You Won’t Believe #3)
  • 10 Tips to Boost Your Muscle Gains
  • The Top 10 Exercises for Building Bigger Shoulders
  • Pose Running Method vs. ChiRunning Guide: Breaking Down Both

Featured Articles

woman-4056081_1280.jpg

Best Cardio Workouts for Women

  It is crucial to find a female weight loss program that incorporates a sufficient amount of cardio workouts if you want to enhance your overall health and wellness. Including cardio exercises in your fitness routine has numerous advantages for women, and locating the right fitness center that offers a comprehensive program can be invaluable. […]

beef-2730393__340.jpg

5 Powerful Bone Broth Health Benefits (You Won’t Believe #3)

  What is Bone Broth? The word “broth” typically refers to a liquid made by cooking bones. However, some broths may also include a small number of bones as part of the cooking process. So, what’s the difference? Cooking time for a regular broth is 45 minutes to 2 hours. Bone broth takes significantly longer […]

Home | About | Contact | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Medical Disclaimer

Copyright © 2025 Dietworks.net